My Sisterâs Toys (And the Man Who Watched)
Chapter 1
The elevator opened onto a hallway that smelled like fresh paint and someone elseâs old life. Mara checked the text againâapartment 4B, key under the matâthen knocked once out of habit before crouching to retrieve it. The door swung open before she could stand.
âYou look exactly like Mom.â
The woman in the doorway was taller than Mara had expected, barefoot in faded black jeans and a thin white tank top that clung where it shouldnât. Dark hair pulled into a messy knot, a few loose strands stuck to her neck. Same sharp cheekbones. Same full mouth. The resemblance hit so hard Mara almost stepped back.
âHalf,â Mara said automatically. âWe only share the dad part.â
âStill.â The womanâEden, according to the lawyerâs emailâtilted her head, studying her. âCome in. Itâs a mess, but the air conditioning works.â
The apartment was small and mostly empty: a couch with a sheet thrown over it, two boxes labeled *kitchen*, a mattress on the floor in the bedroom with the door open. Eden had been sleeping here for three nights already, clearing out their fatherâs things. The will had left the place to both of them equally. One signature and Mara could walk away with her half. That was the plan. Sign, leave, never think about the sister sheâd never met.
Eden handed her a bottle of water from a cooler on the counter. Their fingers brushed. Edenâs were cool from the ice. Maraâs pulse jumped anyway.
âYou flew in this morning?â Eden asked.
âYeah. Figured Iâd get this over with.â
âEager.â
Mara uncapped the bottle and drank so she wouldnât have to answer. When she lowered it, Eden was watching her throat. The look lasted a second too long.
They started with the paperwork because it felt safer. Sitting on the floor with the will spread between them, knees almost touching. Eden read the clauses out loud in a low voice. Every time she leaned over to point at a line, the neckline of her tank gaped. Mara could see the inner curve of one breast, the edge of a dark nipple. She forced her eyes back to the page and felt heat crawl up her neck.
âYou keep staring,â Eden said without looking up.
âYou keep leaning.â
Edenâs mouth curved. She sat back on her heels, stretching, arms overhead. The tank rode up, exposing a strip of stomach and the soft underside of her breasts. No bra. Maraâs mouth went dry.
âI didnât bring much,â Eden said. âWasnât planning on company.â
âI can go ...